Saltwater Showdown: Choosing Between The Ascension Bay and Christmas Island

When it comes to fly fishing, enthusiasts are constantly on the lookout for the next great adventure. Two destinations that have captured the hearts of anglers worldwide are Ascension Bay in Mexico and Christmas Island in Kiribati. Both offer unique experiences, but the question remains: which one is better suited to your fishing style? In this extended exploration, we’ll delve even deeper into the similarities and differences between these two angler’s paradises.



Ascension Bay: The Mexican Gem


Bonefish Bonanza: Both Ascension Bay and Christmas Island are renowned for their exceptional bonefish populations. Anglers can expect thrilling bonefishing experiences, with opportunities to catch these elusive and powerful creatures that gracefully navigate the shallow flats.

Stunning Saltwater Flats: The crystal-clear waters of Ascension Bay mimic the allure of Christmas Island’s flats. These expansive, shallow areas provide the perfect hunting ground for a variety of species, creating an angler’s dream come true beneath the sun-drenched Mexican skies.




Permit Pursuit: Ascension Bay steals the spotlight with its excellent permit fishing opportunities. If the pursuit of this challenging species is on your bucket list, the bay’s flats offer a chance to test your skills against the wily permit—a test of patience and precision that adds an extra layer of excitement to your fishing expedition.

Mexican Cultural Blend: Immerse yourself in the rich Mexican culture surrounding Ascension Bay. After a day of fishing, explore local markets, indulge in authentic cuisine, and witness the vibrant traditions that make this destination more than just a fishing spot. The fusion of angling and cultural experiences creates memories that extend beyond the waters.

Varied Ecosystem: Ascension Bay’s ecosystem is a marvel in itself, with mangroves, seagrass beds, and lagoons contributing to the rich biodiversity. This diversity extends beyond the fishing experience, offering a unique opportunity to appreciate the interconnectedness of nature.



Christmas Island: The Pacific Playground


Blue Water Bliss: For those who crave offshore adventures, both Christmas Island and Ascension Bay provide access to blue water wonders. The thrill of chasing pelagic species in the open ocean is an experience shared by anglers in these diverse locations. The vastness of the Pacific Ocean becomes your playground, promising exhilarating encounters with powerful gamefish.

Diverse Species: Beyond bonefish, both destinations offer a diverse array of species to target. From trevally and triggerfish to the mighty tarpon, anglers can test their skills against a wide range of gamefish. The variety of species ensures that every cast brings the anticipation of encountering a different underwater adversary.




Giant Trevally (GT) Adventure: One significant difference is the thrilling opportunity to target Giant Trevally (GT) at Christmas Island. These apex predators prowl the Pacific waters surrounding the island, providing anglers with an adrenaline-pumping challenge. Ascension Bay, while teeming with other exciting species, doesn’t offer the same GT fishing experience. The aggressive nature and powerful runs of GTs create a unique dimension to your saltwater fly fishing adventure at Christmas Island.

Isolation and Untouched Beauty: Christmas Island’s allure lies in its isolation and untouched natural beauty. Far removed from the hustle and bustle of civilization, the island offers a true escape into a pristine, unspoiled environment. The feeling of being surrounded by untouched landscapes amplifies the sense of adventure and exploration.

Coral Reefs and Atolls: While Ascension Bay boasts its unique charm, Christmas Island’s coral reefs and atolls add an extra layer of excitement to the fishing experience. The underwater landscapes create an otherworldly backdrop for your angling pursuits. Snorkeling amidst vibrant coral formations adds a dimension of wonder to your fishing expedition.

Traditional Kiribati Culture: Christmas Island provides a unique opportunity to interact with the traditional Kiribati culture. Engage with the local communities, learn about their customs, and appreciate the simplicity of life on the island. This cultural immersion adds depth to your overall experience, making your journey more than just a fishing trip.

Choosing Your Fishing Haven

In the end, the choice between Christmas Island and Ascension Bay boils down to your personal preferences and fishing style. If you seek a cultural blend, the vibrant Mexican experience of Ascension Bay may be your calling. On the other hand, if isolation and untouched beauty are what you crave, the unspoiled paradise of Christmas Island awaits, surrounded by the vast expanse of the Pacific.

Whichever you choose, both destinations promise unforgettable fly fishing adventures that will etch memories into your angler’s heart. So, ask yourself: Is it the spirited culture of Mexico or the isolated tranquility of the Pacific that resonates with your fishing soul? The answer lies in the ripples of the waters you choose to cast your fly, creating a narrative that extends far beyond the surface of the sea.


If you’d like to learn more about either of these world-class destinations, please contact our team here or email us at info@gotfishing.com.